How Could Palpatine Be Defeated, If He Can See The Future?

Emperor Palpatine boasts about his ability to foresee the future in Star Wars, but that didn’t seem to help him when he was defeated thoroughly more than once. In Return of the Jedi, Palpatine remarks, “Everything is proceeding exactly as I have foreseen,” referring to Vader’s desire to find Luke Skywalker and turn him to the dark side. Luke does come to Vader as Palpatine predicts, but never gives in to the dark side, pulling Vader back to the light instead and giving his father the perfect chance to turn on his master. Palpatine clearly didn’t expect any of that.

Palpatine is a master manipulator, carefully orchestrating every detail of the galaxy’s Separatist conflict and the Clone Wars to place him in a position to seize control and gain a powerful new apprentice. Despite that, his downfall is relatively simple, and it happens twice. He doesn’t predict Luke Skywalker redeeming Darth Vader, which leads to his first defeat on the second Death Star, and despite decades of preparation, he doesn’t expect Rey to defeat him a second time on Exegol. So, how does his knowledge of the future really work?

Palpatine Pursued Knowledge Of The Future

Project Harvester expanded these efforts

Throughout Star Wars, Palpatine relentlessly seeks out ways to look into the future and use it to his advantage. He understands that through the Force he can glimpse visions of the future, and he tries to collect as much information as he can through those visions. Paired with his talent for strategy, these glimpses of the future allowed Palpatine to become incredibly powerful as he stayed multiple steps ahead of his adversaries. He eventually created an initiative codenamed Project Harvester to expand his access to those visions by utilizing Force-sensitive children.

First mentioned in Star Wars: The Clone Wars, Project Harvester involved the kidnapping of Force-sensitive children across the Galactic Republic. Palpatine began Project Harvester in preparation to destroy the Jedi, intending to raise Force-sensitive children in the ways of the dark side and use them later as his agents. Knowing that the Force could supply Force sensitives with visions of the future, Palpatine used the children’s abilities to increase his own knowledge of the future. With these additional visions at his disposal, his knowledge of the future was more thorough, even if they were a collection of fragmented details.

Is Yoda Right That The Future Is Always In Motion?

Fate may still play a bigger role

When Luke has a Force vision of his friends being in danger, Yoda tells him the future is too unknowable to act on, but with every development in the Star Wars franchise, foreshadowing seems like it’s becoming a more crucial aspect of the story. Yoda is more concerned with the present, exemplified by his reluctance to believe in Anakin’s presumptive role as the Chosen One or an emerging threat of the Sith’s return. He doesn’t spend much time searching for the future in visions, despite his advice to the then-Padawan Obi-Wan Kenobi to “be mindful of the future.”

What Yoda means is that no Force vision is ever telling the full story and that being consumed with a single detail that may or may not come true is never helpful. Sometimes, knowing a single detail about the future causes more harm than good, like when Anakin self-destructs in his attempt to save Padmé. Anakin still loses his wife, but everything else goes up in flames as well as a result of his obsession.

The concept of fate might play a bigger role than Yoda is letting on, but the choices made in the present will always carry weight. When he tells Luke that the future is always in motion, he’s advising Luke to act rationally and continue his training so that he might stand a chance against Vader. Still, had Yoda supported Anakin’s curiosities and anxieties concerning his own visions, the future might have followed a different path.

Related

20 Best Yoda Quotes Of All Time

Master Yoda always had the right bit of wisdom at the right time, and his quotes have made him one of the most iconic characters in all of fiction.

The Nature Of The Force Explains Why Visions Are Flawed

The light and dark sides counteract one another

The Living Force is by definition a moving thing. Because of the constant push-pull relationship between the dark side and the light side, certain Force-sensitive individuals might be privy to certain future events, but their allegiance to the light or dark can fool them. The abilities powered by each respective side of the Force often completely counteract each other, and the same goes for visions of the future. Palpatine was so entrenched in the dark side that his visions were unable to comprehend the possibility of the light counteracting him.

Actions that were fully inspired by the light side of the Force, such as Darth Vader’s redemption, would be completely hidden from Palpatine. He believed he was on an unobstructed path to victory because he only saw moments of the future that pointed to his success. When Luke breaks through Vader’s darkness and reminds him who he is, it’s an act so powered by the light side of the Force that Palpatine’s visions couldn’t comprehend it. The same goes for Rey joining forces with all the power of past Jedi; an act of pure goodness that completely counteracts Palpatine’s visions.

Palpatine Could Predict Everything But His Defeat

His focus on the dark kept him from seeing the light

Despite his incredible ability to use knowledge of the future to his advantage, Palpatine’s pride keeps him from fully understanding what he sees. He believes the Force is telling him that victory is his, regardless of the Jedi’s involvement. While that was true of his actions that brought about the fall of the Republic and the destruction of the Jedi Order during Order 66, he underestimates his enemies’ capacities to oppose him. He’s sure Vader is fully consumed by the dark side, just like he never considers Rey could access “all the Jedi” to rival his power of “all the Sith.”

For such a powerful character, Palpatine’s multiple defeats ultimately boil down to something very simple. His lack of preparation and overconfidence prevent him from even considering that there could be more to his visions besides the moments that look like victory. Vader’s redemption and Rey’s triumph on Exegol catch Emperor Palpatine by surprise not only because he doesn’t see those specific events in his visions, but also because he considers himself invincible. The danger of pride is a strong theme in Star Wars, and even its oldest villain isn’t immune to that.

Emperor Palpatine / Darth Sidious

The senator for Naboo, Palpatine rose to power and influence during the dying days of the Republic. In reality, his public persona was just a mask; he was really Darth Sidious, greatest of the Sith Lords, and he used his political skills and Machiavellian cunning to bring down both the Republic and the Jedi. Palpatine ruled his Galactic Empire for decades, until he was betrayed by his apprentice, Darth Vader. Even this wasn’t enough to stop the Emperor, however, as he was resurrected by his followers – only to be defeated once again.

Died

Star Wars: Episode IX- The Rise Of Skywalker

Alliance

Sith, Empire

Race

Human

Expand