Getting into the Christmas spirit with A Nonsense Christmas with Sabrina Carpenter is great, but there is another special that is a great follow-up which came out nine years earlier. Netflix gave Sabrina Carpenter the green light to make a Christmas special with music, celebrity guests, comedy, and much more for the 2024 Holiday season. The special is great for fans of Sabrina, and there are some wonderful comedy beats that make it a genuine pleasure to watch.
However, if watching Sabrina Carpenter’s comedy special has just got viewers looking for the next great Christmas watch, Netflix has that covered too. Nine years earlier, Netflix called on the incredible comedy actor Bill Murray to create a Christmas special in a similar vein to Sabrina’s, with music, celebrity guests and skits. But on top of all that, they hired Sofia Coppola, daughter of the legendary director Francis Ford Coppola, and an incredibly talented director herself, to come and put the special together.
A Very Murray Christmas Is Another Great Netflix Christmas Special To Watch After A Nonsense Christmas With Sabrina Carpenter
Netflix Is Killing It With Quality Christmas Specials
A Very Murray Christmas is actually the second time that Bill Murray and Sofia Coppola collaborated, and the quality of the special is all the better for it. Just like the Sabrina Carpenter special, A Very Murray Christmas has some wonderful musical moments, with Murray showing off his talents for singing. They roped in major celebrity guests such as George Clooney, Miley Cyrus, and many more, and the comedy is top tier. As a result, it’s another great Christmas special to get viewers in the mood for the holidays.
Related
A Nonsense Christmas With Sabrina Carpenter Soundtrack Guide: Every Song & Who Performs Them In Netflix’s Special
Sabrina Carpenter’s musical comedy special, A Nonsense Christmas With Sabrina Carpenter, includes a host of songs, old and new, for the holidays.
However, there are a couple of differences, such as a greater focus on the comedy aspect, and the Bill Murray special is clearly aimed at slightly older viewers, while the guests in Sabrina Carpenter’s call-out to a younger audience. All of that said, both shows are spectacular, and they have their own strengths. Both specials have a lot in common, and both are a great choice to watch this holiday season.
How A Very Murray Christmas Compares To Bill Murray & Sofia Coppola’s Other Movies
Sofia Coppola And Bill Murray Are A Dynamic Duo
A Very Murray Christmas also benefits from the familiarity between Sofia Coppola, the director, and Bill Murray, the star. Back in 2003, the pair worked together on Lost in Translation. The film was incredibly well received, earning four Oscar nominations, including one for Bill Murray’s performance, and a win for Best Original Screenplay for Coppola. This marks the beginning of their collaborative efforts, and while it is very different to a Christmas special, the movie is an excellent comedy drama with strong emotional beats throughout.
Then, years after reuniting for A Very Murray Christmas, Coppola and Murray got together to create an original film for Apple TV+. On The Rocks is also a comedy drama, this time starring Rashida Jones opposite Murray. However, the film centers on a connection between a father and his daughter, rather than an aging movie star who seeks the companionship of a young woman. Both films have some elements in common with each other, but they are very different to A Very Murray Christmas, which is in turn similar to A Nonsense Christmas with Sabrina Carpenter.

A Nonsense Christmas with Sabrina Carpenter is a festive variety music special directed by Sam Wrench. The film features pop star Sabrina Carpenter performing holiday hits, engaging in unexpected duets, and including comedic cameos, blending music and entertainment in a seasonal celebration.
- Director
- Sam Wrench
- Release Date
- December 6, 2024
- Writers
- Sabrina Carpenter , Chappell Roan , Tyla , Kali Uchis , Shania Twain , Nico Hiraga , Quinta Brunson , Cara Delevingne , Kyle Mooney , Jillian Bell , Owen Thiele , Sean Astin , Megan Stalter
- Cast
- Sabrina Carpenter , Chappell Roan , Tyla , Kali Uchis , Shania Twain , Nico Hiraga , Quinta Brunson , Cara Delevingne , Kyle Mooney , Jillian Bell , Owen Thiele , Sean Astin , Megan Stalter